Stories of Tie Up Games

Round 1 - The Mafia’s 1st Victim
Some sat on the couches, some sat on the floors. Chairs had been gathered from other rooms in the cozy 2-bedroom apartment.

Plenty of places for plenty of men to spend the afternoon tied up.

“Check your phones”, said Harry, the game’s current narrator, “I texted you your role. Mafia members should make a group chat and text me who they want voted out. Villagers, I sent you your job this round.”

Everyone began typing. The Mafia picked a target, the villagers each responded to Harry’s question.”

“Times up”

The group of kinky friends waited to see who was on the chopping block.

“As a new day dawns on the little village,” Harry narrated, “one of you finds yourself waking up to darkness. Unable to move. Unable to see or shout for help.”

Harry dramatically turned to Luke.

“I'm sorry Luke, you have been captured by the Mafia.”

“Oh fuck y'all.” Luke said, as the other men in the room began playfully teasing and taunting him.

“The Mafia chose the target,” Harry continued, “but the villagers ultimately decided how you’ll soon find yourself trussed up.”

Harry allowed a pause for a dramatic effect, then read out Luke's sentence.

“Mummified. Briefs. Tape gag. Vibrating buttplug.”

Harry smiled at Luke as he read that last part, since Luke had actually chosen the vibrating butt plug as the “entertainment” for the victim... before knowing the victim would be himself.

“So that we can all appreciate his nice body and tight briefs,” Dasol said, “can we use saran wrap and clear tape, sir?”

“Great idea,” Narrator Harry replied, and the men got to work.

They stripped Luke down to his underwear, and upon finding he was in boxers, Seth offered his own briefs, a full size smaller than Luke’s. Seth stripped naked and Luke reluctantly put his “gift”.

Selim lubed up a remote control vibrating buttplug and ‘helped’ insert it before Luke put on Seth’s briefs. At the same time, other mrn saran wrapped each of Luke's arms. Once the internal sleeves were done, the men wrapped the clear wrap around Luke's whole body.

When he was properly mummified they ran a few loops of packing tape around his shoulders, arms, beltline, thighs, and ankles, just to make sure the wrapping wouldn't come loose. They left his feet unwrapped, as a fun little promise of tickle torture later.

They gagged Luke with white duct tape. Harry made sure the gag was not overly secure, so in an emergency Luke could lick and chew it so it loosened and he could call for help. Harry promised Luke that if he got the gag off for any reason other than a medical emergency, he would personally shove a sock in his mouth and wrap the tape around his head so tight he'd barely be able to even grunt.

The men brought Luke to the bed in one of the apartment’s rooms. They kept the door open so they could see him. Selim took the remote to the buttplug, and the group returned to the couches to prepare for the witch-hunt.

Round 1 - The Witch-hunt
With Luke mummified in the other room, and Selim nonchalantly playing with the remote that controlled the first victim’s vibrating buttplug, the rest of the men returned to the couches to vote.

“It’s definitely Selim.” Seth said.

“What!?” Selim said, “That's so aggressive, it's probably you.”

“Nah I'm with Seth,” added Chet the Jock, “Luke just had Selim tied up for like two weeks a couple days back. Dude probably wants revenge. Plus he took the buttplug.”

“That would be too obvious,” Nerdy Artis said, “it'd be stupid for Selim to go for someone we know he has a recent history with. Someone is trying to throw him under the bus.”

“Hey Harry?” Chet said.

“Call me sir.”

“No fucking way dude, not even for a game.” Chet continued with his original question, “how many Mafia are there?”

“2.” Harry made a mental note to punish Chet for that later.

“It's Selim and Artis.” Chet said.

“You're wrong, it's absolutely not, y'all can't really be falling for this!?” Artis said.

“Vote Selim this time and Artis next round?” Seth asked. The men in the circle nodded and gave thumbs up.

“You guys are all so wrong,” Selim said, “you’re going to regret this.”

Harry called for a vote. Everyone except Artis and Selim voted for Selim.

“Lemme truss him up,” Nahum said, “the big guy likes rope. I reckon we ought to make sure he's happy since he'll be tied for a good long while.”

“He should be in a singlet,” Artis said, trying to suggest something he knew some of the other guys would like as a way to win back favor in the group.

Selim changed into a wrestling singlet and let Nahum lead him to the couch. The expert roper tied Selim's wrists to his forearms so they were bent like chicken wings. He did the same with Selim's legs and ankles. Then he ran rope under and around the couch to stick Selim in place.

Chet shoved Selim’s discarded boxer briefs in the bound man's mouth and wrapped duct tape around his head to seal them in. Since Selim was right in front of them and had hands free to snap, they decided it was okay to truly gag him.
To give the bound man something to do for the rest of the game, they let him keep the remote to Luke's buttplug.

“O m gee I'm in LOVE with your new couch,” slutty Dasol said, as he sat saddling Selim.

Wearing the shortest inseam shorts any of the other men had ever seen, Dasol angled himself so he could grind his ass against Selim's dick. The tied man's hard cock strained against the tight singlet, desperate for Dasol’s hole.

Dasol continued his close contact lap-dance as Harry directed the men to check their phones for round 2...



We're going to make this interactive! It's a game after all. Vote for who you think the Mafia is. The next chapter will be the Mafia picking their victim (you don't pick that) but the following chapter will be the witch hunt (you do pick that). I'll reset the poll after each witch hunt.

Note, you can vote for people already out because the alliance of people aren't revealed when they're voted out (there's going to be other ways to learn whether someone voted out was Mafia or not).

If you have any suggestions for bondage positions, feel free to give them. I'll write in some, but I might not take all of them because I have some I've been excited to write about too.

I'm going with Chet, the best defense is an aggressive offense.

Also extremely tempted to vote for Harry.

In a similar vein, I've got to vote for Seth, as he was among those aggressive accusers.

Loving this set up! I do feel very bad for Luke and Selim, out already, bound so early, but I suppose its only fair, since we just spent a long time with them in the last story! But I do feel bad, since Luke is one of my favorites of this group!

My vote is for Dasol. This is an interesting start, looking forward to see where this goes.

Thoroughly enjoy the most competitive guy being the one to get tied up first. Love the detail about Luke being the one to choose the buttplug, too!

Yay! Thanks for the comments y'all, I'm glad y'all are liking this story so far.

blackbound wrote: 1 week ago I'm going with Chet, the best defense is an aggressive offense.

Also extremely tempted to vote for Harry.

I was wondering if anyone would try to vote Harry / how long it would take for someone to suggest that. I would not have guessed first comment but I'm so glad you did! Overthrow the GM, viva la revolution!

I'll add Harry to the vote-able list for the next witch-hunt. I have an idea for hel the game can progress if the leader gets usurped.

gag1195 wrote: 1 week ago In a similar vein, I've got to vote for Seth, as he was among those aggressive accusers.



Loving this set up! I do feel very bad for Luke and Selim, out already, bound so early, but I suppose its only fair, since we just spent a long time with them in the last story! But I do feel bad, since Luke is one of my favorites of this group!

Being too aggressive in these things really puts a target on your back!

Yeah 100% I had them get got first so we can focus on other people AND because they don't need any build up for fans to understand their vibe/dynamic going into the game.

That being said, I've built into the rules a way for people who are out to get back in... So they might not be out for good....

Guardianbound wrote: 1 week ago My vote is for Dasol. This is an interesting start, looking forward to see where this goes.

Dasol's vote is also probably for Dasol. He's been unrestrained longer than he'd like already!

Croup wrote: 1 week ago Thoroughly enjoy the most competitive guy being the one to get tied up first. Love the detail about Luke being the one to choose the buttplug, too!

I remember playing (the not kinky version) of Mafia in college and people always targeted this one dude who was too good a board games / social games. They just assumed he was gonna be a threat and took him out.

About to post the next chapter. This will just be Mafia's pick so it won't take into account the poll.

As of right now (10/11), Seth is currently in the lead, so I'm going to write the next witch-hunt where he is voted out! I'll post that in a day or two.

In the meantime feel free to vote or change your vote as the story goes on. Before writing each chapter I'll check the status of the poll and use it to make decisions about the story.

Round 2 - The Mafia’s 2nd Victim

“The Mafia have chosen their next victim.” Harry said, “and the people have chosen the mystery victim’s predicament.”

Everyone waited to hear who would be next and what their fate would be.

“Late last night, after the masses accused Selim and took him as a prisoner,” Harry narrated, “Jurgen went to the bar to meet up with someone he'd been chatting up. While the two talked, Jurgen found himself getting lightheaded. The Mafia had slipped something in his drink.”

“Oh shoot,” Jurgen said, though his face showed more excitement than disappointment.

“Jurgen wakes up” Harry continued, “and finds himself stripped naked, locked in a straitjacket, hooded, and gagging on another man's cock!”

The other guys cheered and began gathering the supplies to restrain Jurgen.

Jurgen stripped naked and let the men strap him in the jacket. They pulled the straps tight enough that he couldn't ignore the pressure on his arms, chest and crotch. The straitjacket had openings for his sensitive nipples. His dick stood straight up, eager for what was coming next.

Carlo smiled and pulled a hood over Jurgen’s head. Jurgen couldn't see, and his hearing was significantly muffled. His mouth remained unblocked, and the hood had two nostril holes for his nose.
“What's the gag supposed to be?,” Ricky asked.

“The selected villager just said ‘our cocks’.” Harry replied.

Jurgen smiled at the sound of that.

The men guided him to the floor so he was kneeling. Then the men lined up to take turns using Jurgen's throat.

All except newcomer Mateo, who stood back and watched.

Carlo finished fucking Jurgen's throat, though not to completion - he needed to save himself for whatever was coming later. He noticed Mateo standing back and went to check in on the new guy.

“Hey man,” Carlo said, “you okay?”

“Yeah,” Mateo said, “yeah man, I'm having fun.”

“Why aren't you getting in there?” Carlo asked.

“I don't know,” Mateo said, “things ramped up really quick, like we're 20 minutes in and some guy is getting passed around.”

“You can tap out,” Carlo said, “it can be a lot. We all know each other. We do this sort of thing all the time. No one will be upset if you feel uncomfortable and have to rain check.”

“No. I really wanna be here.” Mateo said, “and I do want to face fuck him. And I do kinda want to be tied up. It's just kinda hard to take the first step, you know.”

Carlo smiled and patted Mateo on the back.

“I got an idea, stay here.”

Carlo returned with a leather head harness and a leash.

Mateo’s heart started to race. Mateo adjusted his jeans to accommodate his growing erection.

“I'm going to lock you in this,” Carlo said, “put you on this leash, and take control. You don't need to worry about what you will say. You don't need to get in your head about what you will do. Let me worry about all that. You can just play the game and go with flow.”

Mateo smiled and nodded. He opened his mouth wide, expecting some sort of stuffing.

“Wow, you are so eager.” Carlo said, giving the newcomer he'd taken under his wing a playful slap on the ass, “they'll be time for a true gag later. Right now though, I'm just covering your mouth. But if you get voted out, that's a different story.”

Carlo strapped Mateo’s face in the head harness, then locked it closed with a padlock. Then he locked a leash to the ring on Mateo’s harness’ neck. Carlo made a big show of putting the keys to those locks in his pockets. Carlo led Mateo over to the straightjacketed fucktoy.

“Hey,” Harry said, noticing one of the still-very-much-in players had been gagged, “what's this all about?”

“Don't worry,” Carlo said, “he's still in the game. His hands aren't tied and he can use his phone. I'm just helping him get comfortable.”

Mateo nodded so Harry would know he was on board. Harry nodded and gave a thumbs up.

“In that case,” he said, “Carlo, thank you for giving our new friend a warm welcome. Mateo, you're lucky, he's a good one. Just be careful, Carol's definitely quicker to tie people up than to let them go.”

Carlo dragged Mateo so he was standing in front of Jurgen. Despite Mateo having his hands free, Carlo unzipped the man's jeans and pulled his cock out for him.

“I want you to fuck his throat,” Carlo ordered, “but don't cum.”

Mateo nodded and got to work.

Jurgen couldn't have asked for a better outcome. He was comfortably -but still strictly- restrained. His mouth was being used by a bunch of guys, and he couldn't even see who he was sucking off. Each new dick was a surprise, and everyone had a very different rhythm and different approach to how active or passive they were being. Some men let him do all the work, others grabbed his hooded head and used it as they pleased.

When everyone was done getting sucked off by Jurgen, the men took their places around the circle.

Dasol returned to giving Selim a lap-dance, whispering about how good Jurgen's blowjob had felt. He reached down and tickled the couch-bound man's spandex-covered cock, and was pleased to see a small spot of precum.

Carlo brought Mateo over to where he was sitting and left him locked in the harness.

Seth sat on the floor on one side of Jurgen and began teasing the straitjacketed prisoner’s exposed cock. Ricky sat on the other side and started teasing Jurgen's nipples.

Sounding faintly from the bedroom, Luke's grunts and moans added a nice backing track as the group prepared for the second Witch Hunt vote.

I hate to be a stickler, but it appears that Jurgen was left ungagged after everyone had their turn... I think he needs to suck on a dildo or plug or something to honor the spirit of his defeat...

And Mateo! Quickly rising the ranks! I do hope Carlo keeps trying to add more and more items and secretly/subtly restraining Mateo each round while trying not to get caught! I'm also now thinking that Mateo might be one of the mafia... just a hunch. The shy, quiet, new guy secretly orchestrating the kinky demise of his new friends?

gag1195 wrote: 1 week ago I hate to be a stickler, but it appears that Jurgen was left ungagged after everyone had their turn... I think he needs to suck on a dildo or plug or something to honor the spirit of his defeat...

And Mateo! Quickly rising the ranks! I do hope Carlo keeps trying to add more and more items and secretly/subtly restraining Mateo each round while trying not to get caught! I'm also now thinking that Mateo might be one of the mafia... just a hunch. The shy, quiet, new guy secretly orchestrating the kinky demise of his new friends?

They definitely need to fix that with Jurgen, he's getting off too easy!

Glad you liked the Mateo intro. If he is Mafia, Carlo subtly restraining him more and more will definitely make his takedown easier. Unless of course Carlo is Mafia... Or neither of them are

Round 2 - The 2nd Witch Hunt

“Does anyone have any accusations?” Harry asked.

“Artis next,” Chet said, as if it were a foregone conclusion, “just like we planned. Let's vote.”

“Wait, are we not gonna talk about how sus Carlo just was?” Seth said, he gestured at muzzled Mateo, “what’s all this about?”

“I'm just helping him get comfortable,” Carlo said, putting his arm around Mateo, “he was too in his own head, we've all been there.”

“Bruh what happened to the fucking plan?” Chet said, “Selim then Artis, I fucking promise you it's the two of them, we could win this game right now.”

“Wait, game-daddy,” Dasol said, “do we get to know if Selim was Mafia?”

“No,” Harry said, “you won't know when someone is voted out if they are Mafia or not. But there's a different detective each round… someone who gets to ask me the identity of one other player in secret, they can choose someone in game or out.”

“Who’s been the detective?” Artis asked the group, “either round. What did you find out?”

“I was detective this round,” Seth said.

“Who’d ya pick?” Nahum asked, “what are they?”

“I can't just say who it is,” Seth said.

“Literally you can” Artis replied, “dude we need to know. Whether the dude you picked is Mafia or not, it gives us good info.”

“They'll just have a target on their back,” Seth said.

“Holy shit,” Artis said, “just tell us. We all have a target on our back!”

“Yeah, actually Seth is Mafia,” Chet said, “he's being real fucking weird. Harry-”

“Call me sir.”

“Absolutely not,” Chet continued, “can a Mafia be a detective?”

“Nope. Only villagers. And it's different each night.”

“Seth's lying about being detective, or he'd tell us who he picked,” Chet said, “he's definitely Mafia.”

“Wasn't there another detective?” Nahum asked, like in round one?

“Maybe they got Mafia-ed or voted out.” Ricky said, “it could be Luke, Selim, or Jurgen.”

“Just tell us who you picked, Seth,” Artis said.

“Nope,” Seth replied, “it's a bad idea. That guy is gonna be a target.”

“I’m ready to vote,” Carlo said.

The other guys agreed. Harry read the room and called the vote.

Seth voted for Carlo.
Nahum voted for Artis.
Ricky voted for Chet.
Dasol voted for himself.
Artis, Chet, Jeremiah, Carlo, and Mateo voted for Seth.

“Y'all I promise it isn't me,” Seth said, “I'll say who I picked, just let us re-vote.”

“Too late,” Harry said, “the vote is cast. You may no longer speak. Townspeople, decide his fate.”

Chet grabbed one of Jurgen’s discarded socks and shoved it in Seth’s mouth. Jeremiah wrapped bondage tape around Seth's mouth and eyes to gag and blindfold him.

Carlo pulled Seth's shirt off of him, while Dasol slowly pulled down Seth’s pants, tickling the captive’s cock through his briefs on the way down.

Nahum tied Seth in a hogtie, starting with a chest harness and arm bindings, before moving to wrists and finally ankles. He tied Seth’s ankles crossed so he'd be more compact and less able to squirm. Nahum tied Seth’s arms back rather than crossed because the group agreed Seth should suffer a little, since if he was a Mafia - he was the enemy, and if he wasn't Mafia - he had fucked them all by not saying who he'd picked as detective.

Chet and Jeremiah lifted Seth onto the coffee table, displaying him in the center of the room.
As Nahum was tying Seth, Carlo brought Mateo into the bedroom with him. The two tickled the spread-eagle Luke. As Luke struggled, Carlo noticed some slack in Luke's mummification.

“Better fix that up.”

Carlo added packing tape, tightly wrapped around Luke to undo his escape efforts.

Dasol continued to tease and edge Selim. Ricky took the opportunity to once again use Jurgen's mouth, assuming that he could lose his freedom any round now.

Harry called everyone back in and told them to check their phones. As Carlo and Mateo returned they saw Jeremiah dripping hot wax onto Seth’s back, Nahum tickling the hogtied centerpiece, and Chet reclining back and kicking his feet up to force Seth to sniff his socks.

The next round began, as more and more men found themselves on the receiving end of both Mobs’ wrath.

Seth! What was that play? Either he was the detective and didn't share vital information, or he was lying and could have made a guess and saved himself! Unless he wanted to get bound? And why did Dasol vote for himself...?

gag1195 wrote: 4 days ago Seth! What was that play? Either he was the detective and didn't share vital information, or he was lying and could have made a guess and saved himself! Unless he wanted to get bound? And why did Dasol vote for himself...?

Well, you summarized what I was going to say... weird moves from these two.

gag1195 wrote: 4 days ago Seth! What was that play? Either he was the detective and didn't share vital information, or he was lying and could have made a guess and saved himself! Unless he wanted to get bound? And why did Dasol vote for himself...?

Definitively a bad move. There's been times playing Mafia back in college where I'd be in actual awe of just how bad of a play someone made. I probably made my own share of bad plays too, I've never been great at social deduction games.

blackbound wrote: 4 days ago Well, you summarized what I was going to say... weird moves from these two.

People are being suspicious, something is definitely up! I'm going to begin writing the next chapter with the results from the poll as they stand now...

Dasol's on the chopping block! Either his weird play backfired, or he's getting exactly what he wants.

Such fun! And silly silly Seth, nothing more sus than claiming to know something but refusing to share, even if I do believe he was telling the truth. Can't wait for the next round!

I think dasol is pretending to be the drunk